His real name was John Innes Michael Stewart and he was a Scottish literary academic. Under the name J I M Stewart he published works of criticism and fiction. He’s best remembered today as Michael Innes, author of the long-running series of detective novels featuring inspector John Appleby.
With the first of these, Death at the President’s Lodging, published in 1936, he more or less invented the donnish mystery story, later developed by Colin Dexter, among others. The last one appeared in 1986.
The books have a highly distinctive tone, featuring elegant prose, peppered with literary references, and a pre-occupation with upper-middle class manners. There is a lot of genteel conversation and they often feature country house settings. There is a vein of absurdity or eccentricity to the point of fantasy running through them. These are not realistic police procedurals.
This may sound off-putting, and the books probably are something of an acquired taste, perhaps not for everybody, but what saves them in my view is that Innes was both a shrewd psychologist and a master of plot. Most of the Appleby novels are compelling and enjoyable. Silence Observed, from 1961, is one of the best, I think.
The plot features artistic fraud, another favourite Innes theme. The title refers to the rule at Appleby’s club, as well as the discretion that he finds applies to sales of rather dubious works of art and the veil of silence that descends when eminent people discover they have been tricked.
Like all Appleby’s cases, it covers a very short period of time. The opening conversation in Appleby’s London club takes place in the morning and after a murder that night and another the following day, the case is resolved on the night of the second day. It’s a peculiarity of the Innes novels that the prose is dilatory but the stories fast paced.
This is a short novel, just under two hundred pages, but it illustrates all Innes’ strengths as well as some of his weaknesses. He has a real flair for dialogue, as well as description. The settings, such as Appleby’s club and a decaying old house in Essex, come vividly to life. There’s an exploration of a seedy shop in Bloomsbury that takes Appleby on to the roof tops of London in a scene worthy of G K Chesterton or Margery Allingham. The brief burst of action at the end is perhaps less convincing. Innes had a taste for frantic chases resembling John Buchan and they don’t always quite come off.
By this stage, although it seems somewhat unlikely, Appleby has become Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police. He moves in the upper echelons of society. What saves the depiction of this from mere snobbery is the other case that is occupying Appleby’s thoughts. It concerns an eighteen-year-old boy in Stepney who has kicked an elderly shop keeper to death for a small sum of money and will inevitably be hanged. He reflects on this while investigating art fraud among the well-heeled.
With Innes, there is always a sense of an erudite and highly intelligent author having a bit of fun, and he passes this on to his readers.
Only Innes could present a fake manuscript by the now obscure poet George Meredith as having been forged by a character from a Rudyard Kipling story. And only Innes would have Appleby notice that one of his police constables is called Henry James.
The Good Reader 