Lenten Thoughts of a High Anglican by John Betjeman

An appropriate poem for this time of year, I think.

I’m not sure exactly when John Betjeman wrote this, but I think it’s one of his later ones from the 1970s. I find it fascinating. With its regular rhythms and rhymes, his poetry is often described as “Victorian” but the sensibility he expresses is quite different, a little bit subversive even, particularly when it comes to sex.

There are many contrasts within what is expressed here. The scene is set in a church and the title refers to a time of restraint, yet he imagines that the beautiful woman he admires is someone living outside conventional Christian morality.

There is a hint of religious doubt here and yet finally the woman’s beauty makes him think of the “unknown God”.

Might there be a veiled autobiographical meaning here? After all, Betjeman himself was “living in sin” as his catholic wife of many years refused to divorce him.       .

Lenten Thoughts of a High Anglican by John Betjeman

Isn’t she lovely, “the Mistress”?
With her wide-apart grey-green eyes,
The droop of her lips and, when she smiles,
Her glance of amused surprise?

How nonchalantly she wears her clothes,
How expensive they are as well!
And the sound of her voice is as soft and deep
As the Christ Church tenor bell.

But why do I call her “the Mistress”
Who know not her way of life?
Because she has more of a cared-for air
Than many a legal wife.

How elegantly she swings along
In the vapoury incense veil;
The angel choir must pause in song
When she kneels at the altar rail.

The parson said that we shouldn’t stare
Around when we come to church,
Or the Unknown God we are seeking
May forever elude our search.

But I hope that the preacher will not think
It unorthodox and odd
If I add that I glimpse in “the Mistress”
A hint of the Unknown God.

Two Plays about John Betjeman by Jonathan Smith

Something of a treat this for Betjeman fans, from Radio 4 extra. These two linked plays, Mr Betjeman’s Class and Mr Betjeman Regrets were first broadcast in 2017. Benjamin Whitrow does an excellent job of capturing the older Betjeman’s distinctive tones. He died during production and his role was completed by Robert Bathurst but you would never know.

The first play deals with Betjeman’s expulsion from Oxford, leading to his time as a prep school teacher, a role for which he is comically unsuited. This is just the latest in a line of disappointments for his father, played very well by Nicky Henson.

Betjeman junior is not the sort of son he would have preferred. He has no sympathy for John’s aesthetic leanings and a major cause of the difficulties between them is John’s lack of interest in taking over the family business. He thinks that his son’s university education has made him look down on his middle-class origins and turned him into a social-climbing time waster.

The second play is perhaps the stronger of the two, building on the themes of the first one. The older Betjeman is a National Treasure now. The success of his poetry and TV appearances have made him wealthy, but he is not altogether happy. He’s confused about his sexuality, and irritated that his poetry, although popular, is dismissed by critics who prefer the complexity of Eliot and Auden.

He ponders the breakdown of his marriage and his wife’s conversion to Roman Catholicism. He reflects that the feeling of guilt this gave him was actually very helpful in inspiring his writing. It was always a slightly difficult relationship and communication between them was conducted in mocking tones. Betjeman wonders whether he might have driven his own son away by talking to him in the same way, without quite realising that he was doing so.

There’s a sad sense of history repeating itself here, and the feeling that the young Paul Betjeman would have been more the kind of son his grandfather wanted. John’s inability to catch the ball when playing beach cricket with his father is repeated in a scene on the beach with his own son, who would prefer a father keener on games.   

Something that comes across very strongly is John Betjeman’s deep love for the Cornwall that featured so often in his poetry, the village of Trebetherick where his parents had a house, and the church of St Enodoc, where Betjeman himself is now buried. For much of the play, Betjeman is seated on a bench in the churchyard musing over his life. Both plays make full use of the fluidity of time and place that audio drama can convey so much more effectively than any other medium.

There is quite a lot of quotation from Betjeman’s poetry in both plays but I’m not sure what the autobiographical source was. He did write a verse memoir of his early years, Summoned by Bells, in which he says that his father’s monument in Highgate cemetery “points an accusing finger at the sky”.

Seaside Golf by John Betjeman

You don’t have to play golf, or even to like sport at all, to see what Betjeman is getting at here. The poem is about one of those rare, fleeting moments when everything just seems to click into place and go perfectly. Even the natural surroundings seem to be on the poet’s side. There’s a sense of optimism and positivity about this poem, and after the nightmare year we have just experienced, I think we could all do with a bit of that.   

Seaside Golf by John Betjeman

How straight it flew, how long it flew,
It clear’d the rutty track
And soaring, disappeared from view
Beyond the bunker’s back —
A glorious, sailing, bounding drive
That made me glad I was alive.

And down the fairway, far along
It glowed a lonely white;
I played an iron sure and strong
And clipp’d it out of sight
And spite of grassy banks between
I knew I’d find it on the green.

And so I did. It lay content
Two paces from the pin;
A steady putt and then it went
Oh, most surely in.
The very turf rejoiced to see
That quite unprecedented three.

Ah! Seaweed smells from sandy caves
And thyme and mist in whiffs,
In-coming tide, Atlantic waves
Slapping the sunny cliffs,
Lark song and sea sounds in the air
And splendour, splendour everywhere.


Betjeman’s Banana Blush

John Betjeman was a National Treasure before that term was in common use. His avuncular, teddy-bear-like presence in his many TV appearances saw to that. His poetry was hugely popular. Lightish, rhyming stuff that scanned, that you could understand, I remember older people saying. The poet of suburbia, of the everyday. In his campaigning for the preservation of Victorian architecture, he seemed to represent an older way of life that was being swept away.

But the themes of his poetry are the classic ones of all serious poetry – love and its absence, death, the existence or not of God. He can be very dark at times. Just think of Croydon, a poem that for me, speaks of the first world war without ever actually mentioning it directly. And there is a sexuality in some of his poems that is quite modern and that the Victorian poets he appeared to resemble would never have dared to publish.

In 1973, the year after he became Poet Laureate, he recorded the LP, Betjeman’s Banana Blush. This was not simply a record of him reading his verse, but placed his voice against music that had been specially composed for the occasion. There had been plenty of recordings of poets reading their work before. T S Eliot and Ezra Pound had done it. There was also the tradition of setting poetry to music, in which the poem became the lyrics of a song, such as John Ireland’s setting of John Masefield’s Sea Fever, or Charles Stanford’s setting of Henry Newbolt’s Drake’s Drum, familiar from the last night of the proms.

The Betjeman record was something a bit different, I think. The music, composed and conducted by Jim Parker, enhances the mood and tone of the poems. Thus, Indoor Games near Newbury, the story of a rather grand and chaperoned inter-war teenage party, alternates between a sort of fanfare-like tune and pastiche 1920s dance music. The melancholy piano, strings and French horn of Business Girls make the single women even lonelier. The slow melody of Youth and Age on Beaulieu River seems to glide like the sailing boat on the water. The Arrest of Oscar Wilde at the Cadogan Hotel is given a fast-paced treatment, creating a comic Victorian stage melodrama effect.

In The Cockney Amorist, the jazzy banjo and clarinet contrast with the tale of lost love. Perhaps most effective of all are the descending strings that open On the Portrait of a Deaf Man, where contemplation of the physical decay of his late father’s body leads the poet to question the existence of God.

It’s not really surprising that Jim Parker has gone on to have a very successful career as a film and television composer, including the theme for Midsomer Murders. The blend of words and music on the Betjeman record creates a sort of film in one’s mind.

Betjeman was sixty eight when he recorded this, but the overall effect makes him a strangely modern figure, having more in common with Ray Davies or Scott Walker, than John Masefield. After all, it’s not a million miles away from the sort of thing that John Cooper Clarke did only a few years later.

It appeared on Charisma Records, an independent company, whose label was a painting of the mad hatter. It was home to a roster of other English eccentrics such as Genesis. Betjeman was rather dismissive of his efforts here but this is a recording that has definitely passed the test of time.

I only discovered this marvellous recording a few years ago, but it certainly gave me a new understanding and appreciation of Betjeman’s poetry. If I not heard this, I might have been tempted to dismiss his writing as a bit “old hat”, as so many people did in the 1970s.

A Banana Blush is a cocktail, I believe, but I am not sure exactly what its ingredients are.