One of the things I like about being a bit older is going back and reading books that I read many years ago to see whether they pass the only test that matters in literature, the test of time. How accurate were my earlier judgements and how much were they a product of the enthusiasm of youth?
Tender is the Night, published in 1934 is not quite as well-known as Fitzgerald’s earlier novel, The Great Gatsby. It is longer and more complex than Gatsby, and does not quite have that sense of perfect construction. It’s a more difficult read but perhaps a more satisfying one.
I always preferred it to Gatsby though, and going back to it, I’m stunned at just how good I still find it to be.
It is the story of American psychiatrist Dick Diver and his marriage to wealthy heiress Nicole Warren, who is his patient before becoming his wife. This takes place mainly in the glamourous locations of the French Riviera and Switzerland in the 1920s. There is also the wider background of the aftermath of the first world war, something we are reminded of during a visit to the abandoned trenches of the western front.
At that time a favourable exchange rate meant that Americans found the dollar went a long way in France. At Gausse’s hotel on the Riviera, the Divers have gathered a group of friends around them, including alcoholic composer Abe North, French-American soldier Tommy Barban and would-be writer Albert McKisko.
This tale of wealthy American expatriates in Europe inevitably recalls the writing of Henry James and Edith Wharton, but there is a lush, poetic feel to the language here and the title is taken from Keats’ Ode to a Nightingale. Yet it is faster paced and there is a fluidity of time that shows the influence of modernism. We are in a different era, the characters are more volatile and there is an undercurrent of violence here with events such as a duel and a shooting featuring in the story. Some of this is similar to the world depicted in Hemingway’s Fiesta.
It’s a very American novel in that most of the references to the British are negative, mentioning the decline of the empire, and one of the few British characters, Lady Caroline Sibley-Biers, is quite decadent.
The novel has a clever flashback structure, opening in the south of France at what is actually the middle of the story, before going back to the beginning in Switzerland in 1917 then resuming in the 1920s and going on to the tragic ending. This gives a mystery element and a dramatic tension to the whole opening part of the novel. What is the secret behind the Divers’ idyllic world and seemingly perfect marriage?
This is enhanced by the whole of that opening section being seen through the eyes of Rosemary, the young film actress who is attracted to Dick Diver. We see the Divers and their seemingly perfect world through her eyes. Dick is attracted to her as well, but it is not immediately apparent why a seemingly happily married man might be tempted to stray. The tensions in the Divers’ marriage are gradually revealed.
Throughout the novel Fitzgerald subtly varies the point of view. This is particularly effective in conveying the way in which Dick declines and Nicole rises, as their relationship changes. At first, the reader hardly notices what is happening, as Dick begins to drink more, and his charm and perfect manners begin to drop away, alienating their circle of friends. The tipping point of the story after which the balance between them shifts is when Dick has an affair with Rosemary in Rome, gets into a fight and is beaten up by the police.
There is some very murky psychology on display here. Nicole’s mental troubles have been caused by sexual abuse by her father. Dick is as much her doctor as her husband, a figure of authority. “Control yourself!” he snaps at her as she begins to unravel. The film that has made Rosemary a star is called Daddy’s Girl. Her mother, too, is a controlling figure who encourages her relationship with the older, married man.
The novel has an autobiographical element, based as it is on Fitzgerald’s marriage to Zelda and their life in France.
Finally, Dick is corrupted by wealth, drink, and endless leisure, his plans to do pioneering work in psychiatry abandoned and his career in tatters. At the end, Nicole and Dick divorce and he disappears into an obscure life as a local doctor back in America. With Nicole cured and now married to Tommy Barban, Dick has served his purpose as far as the Warren family are concerned. “That’s what he was educated for” her older sister cynically says. She had planned for Nicole to have a doctor husband all along, she just didn’t necessarily think it would be Doctor Diver. The reader knows it was a real love, on both sides. As Nicole said “I don’t ask you to love me always like this, but I ask you to remember. Somewhere inside me there’ll always be the person I am tonight.”
The final image is very poignant, as Dick says goodbye to the beach in front of the hotel where the story opened. He and Nicole created a world and now it is all gone.
The later parts of the novel are almost unbearably sad. It is beautifully written and an absorbing, heart-breaking reading experience. It was Fitzgerald’s own favourite of his books and he was rather puzzled by its relative lack of success on first publication, but its reputation has risen steadily ever since.
The Good Reader 